اداء المحفظة الدولية الخطرة المثلى بظل الازمة المالية دراسة تحليلية لعينة من اسواق الاسهم الدولية

المؤلفون

  • ميثم ربيع هادي الحسناوي
  • هبة الله مصطفى السيد علي المنصور

الكلمات المفتاحية:

الازمة المالية، المحفظة الدولية الخطرة

الملخص

ان العولمة الاقتصادية لها اثار ايجابية وسلبية, فالإيجابية تكمن في اتساع قاعدة الفرص الاستثمارية المتاحة امام المستثمر المحلي , اما السلبية فتأتي من ان الاسواق الدولية اصبحت اكثر تكاملا , وهذا ربما يقلل من جدوى اداء المحافظ المنوعة دولياً.
ان الجدلية الفكرية تكمن في التساؤل الاساسي فيما اذا كان اداء المحافظ الدولية تأثر بالأزمة المالية مقارنة بما في قبلها وما بعدها. وفي الواقع ان هذه المشكلة المعرفية كانت ومازالت تشكل جدلاً بالغ الاهمية وعلى المستويين الاكاديمي والتطبيقي . تسعى الدراسة الى بناء المحفظة الدولية الخطرة المثلى وبيان كيفية بناءها واختلاف اوزانها عن المحفظة المحلية المثلى , وبيان مدى تأثر ادائها اثناء الازمة المالية مقارنة بما قبلها وما بعدها . والكشف فيما اذا كان التنويع الدولي للمحفظة الاستثمارية الخطرة المثلى في عصر العولمة يعد أداة مفيدة تسمح لبناء محفظة استثمارية مثلى توفر افضل مبادلة بين المخاطرة والعائد .
أُجرت الدراسة تحليلاٌ مفصلاٌ لأداء المحفظة الدولية الخطرة المثلى بظل الازمة المالية في ضوء البيانات التي تم الحصول عليها لعينة الدراسة المتمثلة بمؤشرات اسواق الاسهم العراقية والدولية , فالأخيرة تم اختيارها على وفق تصنيف مؤسسة فوتسي (FTSE) لعينة مكونة من (53) مؤشر الاسهم سوق دولي , وتم ادخال سوق العراق للأوراق المالية في العينة كون ان الدراسة تهتم بتقييم اداء المحفظة المنوعة دولياً من منظور المستثمر المحلي العراقي. وشملت مدة الدراسة (771) يوم تداول للعينة المدروسة ككل, فبدأت في يوم (1392006) ولغاية يوم (26/05/2011) . اذ ولغرض معرفة تأثر اداء التنويع الدولي خلال الازمة مقارنة بما قبلها , فقد تم تقسيم مدة المعاينة الى ثلاث مدد وبالتساوي وان لكل مدة (257) يوما. وباستخدام العديد من الاساليب المالية والاحصائية فقد خلصت الدراسة الى عدد من الاستنتاجات ومن اهمها :
يختلف اداء المحفظة الخطرة المثلى الدولية اثناء الازمة المالية مقارنة بما قبلها وما بعدها . وقد اظهرت النتائج التحليلية تفوق المحفظة المثلى الدولية على المحفظة المحلية ولجميع المدد . فضلا عن ذلك فأن اداء المحفظة الدولية متباين فأسفرت النتائج التحليلية عن تحسن اداء المحفظة خلال المدة اللاحقة للازمة بالمقارنة مع نظائرها في المدتين المزامنة والسابقة للازمة ما يؤكد على ان اداء المحفظة الدولية الخطرة المثلى يتغير بتأثير الازمة مقارنة بما قبلها وبعدها .
وخرجت الدراسة بعدد من التوصيات ولعل من اهمها : ينبغي على المستثمر العراقي ان ينتقل من البيئة المحلية الى البيئة الدولية للاستثمار المالي لما يترتب عليه جدوى اكبر منعكسة بمبادلة اكثر كفاءة بين المخاطر والعائد . وعدم التعجل في تصفية استثماراته مع استهلال الازمة, اذ ان الاسواق تتأثر بالأزمة بشكل كبير في بدايتها لكن سرعان ما تمتص الاسواق للازمة وتستوعب اثارها وتعود لترتد وتتعافى. وكما اظهرت النتائج في اداء المحفظة الدولية بعد الازمة كان افضل بكثير مما في الازمة بل وحتى ماقبلها .

المراجع

 Books

Alexander ,Gordon J.,& Sharpe ,William F.,Bailey, Jeffery V., Fundamentals Of Investment ,3rd Ed , Prentice Hall, 2001.

Bacon, R. Carl, Practical Portfolio Performance Measurement And Attribution, 2ed, Wiley & Sons, England, 2004.

Bodie, Zvi,& Kane, Marcus, Alan J., Investments And Portfolio Management , 9th Edition, Mcgraw-Hill, USA, 2011.

Bodie, Zvi,& Kane, Marcus, Alan J., Investments,10th Edition, Mcgraw-Hill, USA, 2014.

Bodie,Zvi, & Merton, Robert C.,Cleeton, David L., Financial Economics,2nd Ed, N.J, Prentice Hall,2009.

Brown, Keith C.& Reilly, Frank K., Analysis Of Investments And Management Of Portfolios, 9th, South-Western, 2009.

Chance,Don M. ,An Introduction To Derivatives,4th Ed.,Forth Worth :The Dryden Press,1998.

Elton ,Edwin J.& Gruber, Martin J.,& Brown, Stephen J., Goetzmann, William N. , Modern Portfolio Theory And Investment Analysis, 9th Edition, Printed In The United States Of America,2014.

Elton, Edwin J. And Martin J. Gruber, Modern Portfolio Theory And Investment Analysis, 5th Ed., N.Y., John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1995.

Eun, Cheol S. ,& Resnick Bruce G. ,& Sabherwal Sanjiv : International Financial Management, 6th Edition, Front Matter Preface , The Mcgraw−Hill Companies, 2012.

Fabozzi, Frank J.& Peterson, Pamela P., Financial Management And Analysis, 2nd Edition, Canada, Published By John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published Simultaneously, 2003.

Gitman, Lawrence J.& Zutter, Chad J., Principles Of Managerial Finance, 13th Edition, Manufactured In The United States Of Copyright By Lawrence J. Gitman. All Rights Reserved America, 2012 .

Jones, Charles P., Investments: Analysis And Management, 6th Ed., N.Y.: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.,1998.

Jordan ,Bradford D.,& Thomas W.Miller ,Fundamentals Of Investments : Valuation And Management, 5th Ed,N.Y:Mcgraw-Hill,2009.

Mayo , Herbert B . " Investments :An Introduction " 9th, South-Western, Canada, 2008.

Mayo, Herbert B., Investments: An Introduction, 6th Ed., Fort Worth: The Dryden Press, 2000.

Ross Stephen A.& Westerfield, Randolph W.& Jordan, Bradford D., FUNDAMENTALS OF CORPORATE FINANCE, 8th Ed, Mcgraw-Hill/Irwin, New York, 2008.

Shapiro, Alan C., Multinational, Financial Management, 10th Edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2014.

Solnik,Bruno& Mcleavey, International Investments, 5thed, Pearson Education, Inc., 2004.

 Periodical

Abid, Fathi, Pui Lam Leung, Mourad Mroua And Wing Keung Wong, International Diversification Versus Domestic Diversification Mean-Variance Portfolio Optimization And Stochastic Dominance Approaches, J. Risk Financial Manag, 2, Journal Of Risk And Financial Management ,Issn: 1911-8074, 2014

Arestis, P., Demtriades, P., & Luintel K. Financial Development And Economic Growth: The Role Of Stock Markets. Journal Of Money, Credit And Banking, 33, 16-41. 2001.

Bawa, Vijay, Elton, Edwin J., And Gruber, Martin J. “Simple Rules For Optimal Portfolio Selection In A Stable Paretian Market,” Journal Of Finance, 34, No. 2, June, 1979

Blackman, S., Holden, K., And Thomas, W., Long-Term Relationships Between International Share Prices‘ Applied Financial Economics, (4) 4, 1994.

Bruno H. Solnik, “Why Not Diversify Internationally Rather Than Domestically?” Financial Analysts Journal, July/ August 1974.

Carrieri, F.; Errunza, V.; Sarkissian, S. Industry Risk And Market Integration. Manag. Sci, NO. 50, 2004.

Chen, Son-Nan, And Brown, Stephen J. “Estimation Risk And Simple Rules For Optimal Portfolio Selection,” Journal Of Finance, 38, No. 4, Sept, 1983.

Chen, Son-Nan, And Brown, Stephen J. “Estimation Risk And Simple Rules For Optimal Portfolio Selection,” Journal Of Finance, 38, No. 4, Sept, 1983.

Demaskey, A. L., Dellva, W. L., & Heck, J. L. Benefits From Asia-Pacific Mutual Fund Investments With Currency Hedging. Review Of Quantitative Finance And Accounting, 21(3), 2003.

Diana R. Harrington, “Whose Beta Is Best?” Financial Analysts Journal 39, No. 4, 1983.

Edwards, S. And Susmel, R., Volatility Dependence And Contagion In Emerging Equity Markets, Journal Of Development Economics 66, 2001.

Elbannan, Mona A., The Capital Asset Pricing Model: An Overview Of The Theory, International Journal Of Economics And Finance; Vol. 7, No. 1; 2015.

Eling, Martin,& Schuhmacher, Frank, Does The Choice Of Performance Measure Influence The Evaluation Of Hedge Funds? Working Papers On Risk Management And Insurance No. 29, September, 2006.

Elton, Edwin J., Gruber, Martin J., And Padberg, “Simple Rules For Optimal Portfolio Selection: The Multi Group Case,” Journal Of Financial And Quantitative Analysis, XII, No. 3, Sept, 1977.

Elton, Edwin J., Gruber, Martin J., And Padberg, Manfred W. “Simple Criteria For Optimal Portfolio Selection,” Journal Of Finance, Xi, No. 5, Dec, 1976.

Fletcher, J. & Marshall, A. The Performance Of Uk International Unit Trusts. European Financial Management, 11(3), 2005.

Goel, Deepika,& Chaudhary, Monika Singh, Advantages Of International Portfolio Diversification., International Journal Of Marketing, Financial Services & Management Research, Vol.2, No. 4, April, 2013.

Lessard, Donald R. International Portfolio Diversification: A Multivariate Analysis For A Group Of Latin American Countries, The Journal Of Finance, Vol. 28, No. 3, Jun., 1973.

Mansourfar, Gholamreza.& , Shamsher Mohamad, &Taufiq Hassan, A Review On International Portfolio Diversification: The Middle East And North African Region, African Journal Of Business Management Vol. 4(19), 2010.

Mirza, Nawazish& Shabbir, Ghalia, The Death Of Capm: A Critical Review, The Lahore Journal Of Economics 10 : 2, Winter, 2005.

Mitta, Rishab, The Effects Of Market Capitalization Ratio On GDP Growth And Capital Market Robustness In Newly Industrialized Countries , U Chicago Undergraduate Business Journal, 2014.

Steven L. Heston And K. Geert Rouwenhorst, ‘‘Does Industrial Structure Explain The Benefits Of International Diversification?’’ Journal Of Financial Economics, August 1994.

Stockman, A. C. On The Roles Of International Financial Markets And Their Relevance For Economic Policy. Journal Of Money, Credit And Banking, 20(3), 1988.

 internet

Abidin, Sazali Zainal& Mohamed Ariff , Annuar Md. Nassir , Shamsher Mohamad, International Portfolio Diversification: A Malaysian Perspective, Investment Management And Financial Innovations, 3/2004.

Addae, Dapaah, Kwame& Trecia, Yeo Hui Siang, Currency Risk And International Diversification Of Property Investments: A Singaporean Investor’s Viewpoint, JEL Classification, Eighth European Real Estate Society Conference, Alicante June, 2001.

Ali, Yansen, Simplifying The Portfolio Optimization Process Via Single Index Model, Industrial Engineering Honors Program ,Mccormick School Of Engineering ,Northwestern University, June 2008.

Allen, Franklin,& Ana Babus,& Elena Carletti., Financial Crises: Theory And Evidence, June 8, 2009.

Bordo, M., B. Eichengreen, D. Klingebiel And M. Martinez-Peria “Is The Crisis Problem Growing More Severe?” Economic Policy, Web Appendix, April 2001.

Couto, Gualter,& Duque, Joao, An Empirical Test On The Forecast Ability Of The Bayesian And Blume Techniques For Infrequently Traded Stocks, JEL Classification: G12 - Asset Pricing ,2005.

Crystal, Michelle Swafford, Accounting For Risk A Fundamental Beta Prediction Model, University Of North Carolina At Asheville Senior Economics Research December 2010.

Damodaran, Aswath, Estimating Risk Parameters, Stern School Of Business 44 West Fourth Street New York, 2012.

De Soto, Hernando, Why Capitalism Triumphs In The West And Fails Everywhere Else,New York: Basic Books, 2000.

Dullien, Sebastian,& Kotte, Detlef J., & Alejandro Márquez& Jan Priewe, The Financial And Economic Crisis Of 2008-2009 And Developing Countries, UNITED NATIONS: New York And Geneva, December 2010 ,Copyright , United Nations, 2010 All Rights Reserved UNCTAD/GDS/MDP/2010/1.

Goetzmann, William N., and Kumar, Llok. “Equity Portfolio Diversifications,” Yale School of Management working papers YSM 17, Yale School of Management 2004.

https://www.nyse.com/markets/hours-calendars,2017.

Islam, Abu Hena Md Mamunul & Faisal Md , Investment Diversification A Study On Six European Countries, Student Umea School Of Business Autumn Semester 2011 Master Thesis.

Kamaralzaman, Binti ,Surianor,. Market Integration And International Portfolio Diversification From Malaysian Perspective, Thesis Submitted In Fulfilment Of The Requirements For The Degree Of Doctor Of Philosophy Department Of Finance And Banking Faculty Of Business And Accountancy University Of Malaya, December 2011.

Lehkonen, Heikki ,. Essays On Emerging Financial Markets, Political Institutions And Development Differences, University School Of Business And Economics, April 11, 2014.

Livnat, Joshua &Segal Dan .The Calculation Of Earnings Per Share And Market Value Of Equity: Should. Common Stock Equivalents Be Included,2000 .

Maringer ,Dietmar, Portfolio Management With Heuristic Optimization, Springer, Netherlands, 2005.

Mauer, David C.,& Song Wang, &Xiao Wang, Global Diversification And Ipo Returns, Current Version: January, 2015.

Meyer, Thomas O.& Rose, Lawrence C., Do International Diversification Benefits Continue Beyond The Portfolio Formation Period In A Small Market? Evidence For New Zealand Before And During The Asian Crisis, JEL Classification: F36: Financial Aspects Of Economic Integration; G11: Portfolio Choice; G15, January 2001.

Modigliani, Franco., And Pogue Gerald A. ,AN INTRODUCTION TO RISK AND RETURN CONCEPTS AND EVIDENCE, March 1973 .

MSCI Emerging Markets List, D The S&P Global Broad Market Index, 31 December 2010, P. 2.

Nellor, David C. L., The Rise Of Africa’s “Frontier” Markets A Number Of Sub-Saharan Countries Are Beginning To Attract Investors To Their Financial Markets, Downtown Highrises In Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania., Finance & Development September 2008.

NYSE, Brian Curran, Potential Unlocked... On The Biggest Stage In Business, Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP NYSE IPO Guide, Second Edition, Is Published By Caxton Business & Legal, Inc Www.Caxtoninc.Com Printed By RR Donnelley ISBN 978-0-615-84229-5 NYSE IPO Guide, Second Edition, 2013 Caxton Business & Legal, Inc.

Pal, Parthapratim, Foreign Portfolio Investment, Stock Market And Economic Development: A Case Study Of India. Promoting Development In A Globalized World 2006.

Pritzker, Penny S.& Ken Arnold& Brian C. Moyer, Measuring The Economy A Primer On GDP And The National Income And Product Accounts, BEA’s National Income And Wealth Division, December 2015.

Richard D. Landsberg, JD, Sharpe Ratio And Risk Adjusted Measurement” Advanced Consulting Group Nationwide Financial Services Insurance Company ., Columbus, Ohio, (03/13),2013.

Tehrani, Amir Ehsan, A Comparative Analysis Of The Tehran Stock Exchange And Selected Stock Markets: Evidence From A Correlation Matrix, , Mediterranean University, Gazimağusa, North Cyprus, August 2011.

Vincent , Scott, Is Portfolio Theory Harming Your Portfolio? , Managing Partner Green River Asset Management 503 Albemarle St. Baltimore, MD 21202 United States , 2011.Electronic Copy Available At: Http://Ssrn.Com/Abstract=1840734.

Zweig, Jason, Divarication Pitfalls ,Http: //Jasonzweig. Com/Uploads/ 10.98 youareanegg 1.Pdf, 1998.

Http://Www.Cbe.Org.Eg/En/Auctions/Pages/Auctionsegptbonds.Aspx.

Http://Www.Bankofbotswana.Bw/Content/2009103014034-Government-Bonds.

Https://Www.Centralbank.Go.Ke/Securities/Treasury-Bonds/.

Http://Www.Hnb.Hr/En/Statistics/Statistical-Data/Credit-Institutions/Interest-Rates.

Http://Www.Cbm.Gov.Mm/Content/Issuance-Government-Treasury-Bonds.

Https://Www.Bom.Mu/Markets/Money-Markets/Gmtb.

Http://Dsbb.Imf.Org/Pages/Sdds/Dqafbase.Aspx?Ctycode=MAR&Catcode=INR00.

Http://Www.Cbo-Oman.Org/Inv_Tbills.Htm.

Http://Www.Cbsl.Gov.Lk/Htm/English/_Cei/Ir/I_3.Asp.

Https://Www.Bct.Gov.Tn/Bct/Siteprod/Stat_Index.Jsp?La=AN.

Https://Www.Investing.Com/Rates-Bonds/Vietnam-Government-Bonds.

Http://Www.Iraq-Businessnews.Com/Tag/Government-Bonds/.

Http://Data.Worldbank.Org/Indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?View=Map.

Http://Data.Worldbank.Org/Indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.KD.ZG?View=Map.

Https://Data.Oecd.Org/Gdp/Gross-Domestic-Product-Gdp.Htm.

Http://Www.Worldeconomics.Com/Data/Madisonhistoricalgdp/Madison%20Historical%20GDP%20Data.Efp.

Https://Stats.Oecd.Org/Mei/Default.Asp?Lang=E&Subject=15&Country=AUS.

Http://Stats.Oecd.Org/Index.Aspx?Querytype=View&Queryname=86.

Http://Data.Worldbank.Org/Indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD

Https://Knoema.Com/Tbocwag/Gdp-By-Country-Statistics-From-Imf-1980-2021

Http://Www.Tradingeconomics.Com/Egypt/Forecast .

Ministry Of Statistics And Programme Implementation Planning Commission, Government Of India. Http://Statisticstimes.Com/Economy/Gdp-Growth-Of-India.Php.

World Bank National Accounts Data, And OECD National Accounts Data Files.

Http://Data.Worldbank.Org/Indicator/PA.NUS.FCRF.

Http://Www.Worldeconomics.Com.

Http://Databank.Worldbank.Org/Data/Databases.Aspx.

Http://Esa.Un.Org/Wpp/Excel-Data/Population.Htm.

Https://En.Wikipedia.Org/Wiki/Geary%E2%80%93Khamis_Dollar

Https://Www.Ig.Com/Au/IgIndices/Australia00?CHID=1&QPID=1718673&QPPID=1&S.

Http://Www.Prsgroup.Com/2016.

Https://Ar.Wikipedia.Org/Wiki Lobby.,2017.

Https://Www.Wienerborse.At/Enaustria/Indices/Index-Values/Overview/?ISIN=AT0000A06434&ID_NOTATION=19515307.

Https://Www.Bourse.Lu/Documents/Brochure-TRADING-Indice-45.Pdf.

Https://Markets.Ft.Com/Data/Indices/Tearsheet/Summary?S=OMXH:HEX.

Https://Web.Tmxmoney.Com/Indices.Php?Section=Tsx&Index=^TSX#Indexinfo.

Https://Www.Quandl.Com/Data/XHKG-Hong-Kong-Stock-Exchange-Prices.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/France/Stock-Market.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Portugal/Stock-Market.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Germany/Stock-Market.

Http://Www.Jpx.Co.Jp/English/Markets/Statistics-Equities/Daily/Index.Html.

Http://Countryeconomy.Com/Stock-Exchange/Netherlands.

Https://Www.Quandl.Com/Data/XSES-Singapore-Exchange-Prices.

Https://Www.Nzx.Com/Markets/Nzsx/Indices/NZ50.

Http://Www.Infomine.Com/Investment/Stock-Markets/Indexes/Oseax/All/.

Https://Markets.Ft.Com/Data/World/Countries/Italy?Mhq5j=E3.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Denmark/Stock-Market.

Https://Www.Google.Com/Finance/Historical?Q=KRX:KOSPI&Ei=Hcqjvzl1wo7ybpecs3g.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Spain/Stock-Market#Historical.

Https://Www.Six-Swiss-Exchange.Com/Shares/Explorer/Download/Download_En.Html.

Https://Markets.Ft.Com/Data/Indices/Tearsheet/Historical?S=PX:PRA.

Http://Www.Taiwanindex.Com.Tw/Index/Index/T00.

Http://Www.Borsaistanbul.Com/En/Indices/Bist-Stock-Indices.

Https://Www.Bloomberg.Com/Quote/WIG20:IND.

Https://Www.Federalreserve.Gov/Monetarypolicy/Fomc_Historical.Htm.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Brazil/Interest-Rate.

Https://Www.Cnb.Cz/En/Statistics/Government_Fin_Stat/.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Taiwan/Interest-Rate.

Https://Stats.Oecd.Org/Mei/Default.Asp?Lang=E&Subject=15&Country=POL.

Https://Tradingeconomics.Com/Mexico/Interest-Rate.

Https://Fred.Stlouisfed.Org/Series/IR3TIB01HUQ156N.

Http://Stats.Oecd.Org/Mei/Default.Asp?Lang=E&Subject=15.

Https://Www.Resbank.Co.Za/Pages/Default.Aspx.

Https://Stats.Oecd.Org/Mei/Default.Asp?Lang=E&Subject=15&Country=CHL.

Http://Www.Bnm.Gov.My/Index.Php?Ch=Statistic

Https://Knoema.Com/Pjeqzh/Gdp-Per-Capita-By-Country-Statistics-From-Imf-1980-2021?Action=Export&Country=Vietnam.

Http://Data.Imf.Org/Regular.Aspx?Key=60998119

Https://Www.Ofx.Com/En-Us/Forex-News/Historical-Exchange-Rates/

Http://Data.Worldbank.Org/Indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.KD.ZG?View=Map

Http://Www.Amf.Org.Ae/Ar/Arabic_Economic_Database.

Https://Www.Ofx.Com/En-Us/Forex-News/Historical-Exchange-Rates/.

Http://Www.Rba.Gov.Au/Statistics/Historical-Data.Html#Interest-Rates.

Https://En.Wikipedia.Org/Wiki/New_York_Stock_Exchange.

Http://Www.Menara.Ma/Ar/2014/12/19/1510032 86.Html.

Https://Financial.Thomsonreuters.Com/En/Products/Data-Analytics/Market-Data.Html,Database.

Http://Online.Thomsonreuters.Com/Datastream.

Https://Data.Oecd.Org.

Http://Www.Xe.Com/Currencytables/?From=IQD&Date=2017-03-21

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/ftse.asp2017.

Data.Albankaldawli.Org/Indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD

World Bank National Accounts Data, And OECD National Accounts Data Files.

التنزيلات

منشور

2024-10-22

كيفية الاقتباس

ميثم ربيع هادي الحسناوي, & هبة الله مصطفى السيد علي المنصور. (2024). اداء المحفظة الدولية الخطرة المثلى بظل الازمة المالية دراسة تحليلية لعينة من اسواق الاسهم الدولية. المجلة العراقية للعلوم الادارية, 14(57), 29–66. استرجع في من https://mail.journals.uokerbala.edu.iq:8443/index.php/ijas/article/view/2492